GIJoe Network
    > Joe chit-chat
        > Cartoon look vs. toy look
New Topic    New Poll    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author
Comment
Propadeutic
Member
Posts: 14
(5/5/03 9:57 pm)
Reply

Cartoon look vs. toy look
All the characters on the cartoon differed slightly from the appearance of their figures. In the past we've discussed possible reasons for the differences--artistic license, simplification, greater contrast, etc.

What I'd like to hear is whether you guys tend to prefer the cartoon look of the character or that of the original figure. Which is the definitive appearance in your personal Joe universe?

For reference, the ten with the greatest difference are:

Ace, blue Airborne, Major Bludd, blond Cover Girl, Flint,
Lady Jaye, Ripper, Steeler, Torpedo, and Wild Bill.

For myself, I like Airborne and Steeler better as figures, but the cartoon versions of most characters like Ace, Ripper, and Wild Bill are distinct improvements.

VampII
ezOP
Posts: 61
(5/11/03 8:12 pm)
Reply

Re: Cartoon look vs. toy look
I've heard many reasons why the cartoon appearance of some characters differed from their Hasbro counterparts. Whatever reason(s)they might be,it spurred me to ruin my figures by painting them as the cartoon version.
(P.S. since there is so many,I'll do five per post)
1) I'll start with Flint.
I preferred the cartoon version much more than the action figure.I think it blended in with the 'green' original Joe outfits.My painting of my Flint figure is one that I'm proud of.
2)As for Lady Jaye ,I don't think there was that great a variance between the two:except the hat.I would lean toward the show for her weapon and backpack,too. Once again I side with Sunbow for 'dropping the hat'.
3)The yellow and blue of Wild Bill definately was one of the more contrasting of the show.Although I think it was necessary to veer away from the 'green look' and not have every Joe this way, I will side with Hasbro on this one.
4) Torpedo :What the heck was Sunbow thinking? Albeit,the toy's outfit wasn't 'anything to write home about',at least it had some color.
5) Cobra Officers (gloves/no gloves):It's not much,I just didn't understand why troopers wouldn't wear gloves.Maybe it had to do with color contrast:Black gloved hands holding black weapons. Then why did Cobra Commander,The Baroness,Dr.Mindmender,etc. have black gloves?

Edited by: VampII at: 5/11/03 9:00:01 pm
<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- GIJoe Network - Joe chit-chat - Home -

Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.32
Copyright ©1999-2007 ezboard, Inc.