Gryffindor Tower
    > Philosopher's Stone/Sorceror's Stone
        > Sorceror's Stone?
New Topic    Add Reply

Page 1 2 3

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author
Comment
Shadows arc 
Global user
(2/1/00 9:27 pm)
Reply

Sorceror's Stone?
In Canada and the UK it's called The Philosofers Stone!

Elanor 
Administrator
(2/2/00 5:49 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
yeah, that's the original name. Some weirdo changed it at least for most of the US, which I think is silly.

Elanor of The Shire.
See my Tolkien Sketches and take my Character Identification Test!!
Visit The Tolkien Site of Doom.

Brie Cheese Eater 
Global user
(2/2/00 8:28 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
Yeah, I know, I got the Philosopher's Stone and I was talking to my friend on the phone about it, and she referred to the book as Sorcerer's Stone, so I was like, What?? Are you sure you got that right? We both didn't quite believe each other when we said what was on our book covers. Dumb Scholastic. Changed the name and added Dean Thomas to the Sorting. Ugh.

Brie Cheese Eater
e-mail
webpage

Without wisdom, bravery is recklessness. Without judgment, loyalty is slavery. Without cleverness, cunning is ineffective. Without intelligence and sense, everything is nothing.

Elanor 
Administrator
(2/2/00 9:45 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
What's this about Dean Thomas? I'm confused.

Elanor of The Shire.
See my Tolkien Sketches and take my Character Identification Test!!
Visit The Tolkien Site of Doom.

captain Tarpols 
Administrator
(2/2/00 11:37 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
I'm always confused. BCE I'm going to make you a mod. (I'm just to lazy to do it :) )

----CT. admin at Gryffindor Tower and at James Bond 101 and at Harry Potter and at The Bmilder Fan Club and at The :P :Palace and at The Stuff Council moderator at Harry Potter Mania and at Erebor The Lonely Mountain and at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and at The Shire and at Hogwarts at The 007 board. and at Hoth Echo Base and at Diane's Budgie Talk

Elanor 
Administrator
(2/3/00 5:10 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
Haha, I beat you, Tarpols! ;) Being lazy never got anybody anywhere.

Elanor of The Shire.
See my Tolkien Sketches and take my Character Identification Test!!
Visit The Tolkien Site of Doom.

captain Tarpols 
Administrator
(2/3/00 4:55 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
I was just about to do it too..;)

----CT. admin at Gryffindor Tower and at James Bond 101 and at Harry Potter and at The Bmilder Fan Club and at The :P :Palace and at The Stuff Council and at Cats Are Cute moderator at Harry Potter Mania and at Erebor The Lonely Mountain and at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and at The Shire and at Hogwarts at The 007 board. and at Hoth Echo Base and at Diane's Budgie Talk

Shadows arc 
Global user
(2/3/00 5:54 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
Ha!The American pulishers thought people wouldn't understand Philosophers Stone so they changed it!!!

Hey how do I make a link to my message board when I reply?

Shadows Arc of The Arcian Star Trek Temple.

Elanor 
Administrator
(2/3/00 10:03 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
Grrr. That makes me mad! "Sorcerer's Stone" is no easier to understand, and doesn't even mean anything. The Philosopher's stone is an ancient legend! I'd say all they acheived is making themselves look dumb and offending intelligent American readers who do know what it should have been.

Shadows arc, use your browser to View the Page Source, and that'll tell you lots more about adding links or font changes with html than we ever can!

Elanor of The Shire.
See my Tolkien Sketches and take my Character Identification Test!!
Visit The Tolkien Site of Doom.

captain Tarpols 
Administrator
(2/4/00 10:35 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
I think he meant how do put my board in my sig. :) Elanor will tell you. hehe

----CT. admin at Gryffindor Tower and at James Bond 101 and at Harry Potter and at The Bmilder Fan Club and at The :P :Palace and at The Stuff Council and at Cats Are Cute moderator at Harry Potter Mania and at Erebor The Lonely Mountain and at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and at The Shire and at Hogwarts at The 007 board. and at Hoth Echo Base and at Diane's Budgie Talk

Elanor 
Administrator
(2/4/00 5:57 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
hm, maybe I won't. So there.

Elanor of The Shire.
See my Tolkien Sketches and take my Character Identification Test!!
Visit The Tolkien Site of Doom.

Brie Cheese Eater 
Moderator
(2/5/00 11:11 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
Um... go to your Control Center and put a link there?
I learned all of my HTML from page sources. But I don't suggest you look at this page's. You won't learn a thing. It's all in a string of nonsense. I know I can't make anything out of it.

Brie Cheese Eater
e-mail
webpage

Without wisdom, bravery is recklessness. Without judgment, loyalty is slavery. Without cleverness, cunning is ineffective. Without intelligence and sense, everything is nothing.

Brie Cheese Eater 
Moderator
(2/5/00 11:12 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
Hey, I'm a moderator! :)
Thank you Elanor, or was it CT? Who gets the credit, CT for the idea or Elanor for the actual doing...

Brie Cheese Eater
e-mail
webpage

Without wisdom, bravery is recklessness. Without judgment, loyalty is slavery. Without cleverness, cunning is ineffective. Without intelligence and sense, everything is nothing.

captain Tarpols 
Administrator
(2/5/00 8:28 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
lol. I was going to do it..oh well. your amod. :)

----CT. admin at Gryffindor Tower and at James Bond 101 and at Harry Potter and at The Bmilder Fan Club and at The :P :Palace and at The Stuff Council and at Cats Are Cute moderator at Harry Potter Mania and at Erebor The Lonely Mountain and at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and at The Shire and at Hogwarts at The 007 board. and at Hoth Echo Base and at Diane's Budgie Talk I am currently

HPWiz 
Wizard/Witch
(3/11/00 2:03 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
UK doesn't have any pictures in front of their chapters! :lol :lol ! MWAHHAHA! and my mom said the UK books are cheaper because they have lousy covers! :lol and I have the UK 3rd book, and that's mhow I know, and JKR changed the 1rst books name, not scholastic.I chatted with JKR on scholastic.com, so I should know. And yes they did add dean thomas to the sorting.

L-A-S-A-G-N-A..what do you want for dinner? LASAGNA!

Brie Cheese Eater 
Head master/mistress
(3/19/00 8:30 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
How could you? The Scholastic chat didn't let JKR see any of the chatters' messages.

« Brie Cheese Eater »
Anti-Romance Freak

e-mail: glassdice@earthdome.com
website: www.eccentrica.org/clare
ezboard: nor dlu acy kael

Way down South where bananas grow,
A grasshopper stepped on an elephant's toe.
The elephant said, with tears in his eyes,
"Pick on somebody your own size."
-- Anonymous

Darth Tater 
Muggle
(7/7/00 8:54 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
I think it's really sad that they thought Americans were too dumb to understand the Brittish words so they changed them. Kids all over America got the Brittish versions of previous HP books so they could get them sooner and didn't care. What's this about adding someone to the sorting? Please explain, I'm new to HP

"Many are the strange chances of the world, said Mithrandir, and help oft shall come from the hands of the weak when the Wise falter"

captain Tarpols 
Ultimate Head master
(7/7/00 9:00 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
lol, i know. they didn't change it for lotr. oh well

--CT.

Firebolt N714QS
Muggle
(7/15/00 6:46 am)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
About the changes in the books, I wass reading the 4th one and notice a litlle change. For those of you who have read the US version, when Mr. Weasly had to pay the muggle at the camp grounds, he asked harry to help him out with muggle money, and he was reffering to american dollars, instead of english pounds.

Wizard01 
Muggle
(7/15/00 3:23 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
hmmmm your right, what is the use of having american dollars there??

The New and Improved Discussion Central

captain Tarpols 
Ultimate Head master
(7/16/00 10:33 pm)
Reply

Re: Sorceror's Stone?
hmm good catch!

--CT.

Page 1 2 3 << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- Gryffindor Tower - Philosopher's Stone/Sorceror's Stone -

Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.32
Copyright ©1999-2007 ezboard, Inc.